|
|
|
|
Discoe,_Ben_-_Washed_Ashore Life story, photographs and past events, projects, environmental concerns, opinionated writing, notes on friends, and cultural and scientific links.
| Klimas,_Elizabeth Includes poetry and links.
| Churchman Descendants chart and biography pages for more than 7,200 family members, dating from 1682 when John Churchman came to Pennsylvania from England with William Penn.
| International_Food_Policy_Research_Institute Identifies and analyzes policies for meeting the food needs of the developing world. Site features publications, calendar of events, and datasets.
| Brush_Up_on_Butler Resource site including email list, extensive biographical and bibliographical information, and notes on his influence on later thinkers.
| A_Woman\'s_Life A women's issue site designed by women for women who are challenged with loneliness, dependency in relationships, self esteem, self image, and confidence. Coaching, newsletter and articles offered.
|
|
| Alexa statistic for http://www.angelfire.com/ab3/freewill/CMILecture4.htm |
Please visit: http://www.angelfire.com/ab3/freewill/CMILecture4.htm
|
| Related sites for http://www.angelfire.com/ab3/freewill/CMILecture4.htm |
| Städje,_Jörgen CV, career details, tech projects and photography. | | Goguen,_Matthew Poems and links. | | Gay_Teen_Meeting_Place Online resources for gay and bisexual youth to find other gay/bi teens in their area as well as lists of IRC channels, and Onelist communities. | | The_Sauk Culture and history of the Sauk. | | Kristo Daily horoscope by Kristo, an artist in the Renaissance tradition of Ficino, Paracelsus and Nostradamus. | | Spirit_Touch Psychic medium Sarah Price provides readings and spirit messages by phone, email or in a chat room. Includes rates, her schedule, and excerpts from a forthcoming publication. | | Scientologists_in_Action_Index Provides information on how Scientologists are helping the community with their actions, the Church of Scientology's involvement in ethnic affairs, and eradicating illiteracy. | | 2_Prophet_U Subscription based newsletter designed to inform, enlightened and encourage senior pastors and other ministers. | | Lifeword_Broadcast_Ministries Features radio and TV programs, ministries, and outreach programs by this broadcasting agency of the Baptist Missionary Association of America. | | Culture_and_Religion Print journal supporting discussion of the relations between cultural studies and religious studies. | | Dana_Carson_Ministries World evangelism ministry. Site features an itinerary, statement of beliefs, an online store and daily message. | | Healing_Touch_Ministries,_Inc_ Offering free training and support for churches and leaders addressing anger, dysfunction, addiction, and sexual abuse. Featuring newsletters, books and a sample lesson. | | James_Cook__Celebrated_North_Country_Explorer The life of Captain Cook and his contemporaries as represented by the collections of the British Library, the Captain Cook Birthplace Museum, and other institutions. | | Connecticut_Sexual_Assault_Crisis_Services,_Inc State wide sexual assault information, publications and service hotlines offering training and public awareness programs to Connecticut residents. | | Christian_Discovery_Series Topics to stimulate minds and hearts and encourage search of the Scriptures. | | Pam\'s_Pumpkin_Patch Images of pumpkins already carved. | | Markham,_Kathryn Biographical and professional information | | Livia_de_Almeida\'s_Home_for_Brazilian_Stories Featuring a halloween tale, the legend of The Three Wishes, and a Bororo myth, "How the Stars Came To Be." | | Boyington,_Maj__Gregory_R__\"Pappy\" Site devoted to the US WWII ace and leader of the famed Black Sheep Squadron. | | Taylor__Broadsea Family history, pedigree, photographs, awards and webrings. |
|
Lecture 4—Egoism
Lecture 4—Egoism
Varieties of Egoism: For our purposes, we will be concerned with five forms of egoism: common-sense egoism, psychological egoism, practical egoism, rational egoism, and ethical egoism.
Common-sense Egoism: According to this view, egoism is a vice. It involves putting one’s own concerns over those of others. One’s behavior is egoistic if it involves putting one’s own interests over those of others to an immoderate degree.
Psychological Egoism
Argument For: Human agents always, at least on a deep-down level, are all egoists insofar as our behavior, explainable in terms of our beliefs and desires, is always aimed at what we believe is our greatest good (Baier, 1991, p. 203).
Objection: The psychological egoist confuses egoistic desires with motivation. An agent may act contrary to his desires and what is in his own best interest. People often act in ways that they know are detrimental to their well being. Moreover, what one most wants may not be in their own self-interest (e.g., giving money to Amnesty International rather than buying a new CD). MacKinnon adds that, "Even if it were shown that we often act for the sake of our own interest, this is not enough to prove that psychological egoism is true. According to this theory, we must show that people always act to promote their own interests" (p. 23). If we can find only one counterexample to psychological egoism, then it is not true.
Egoism as a Means to the Common Good
Argument For: According to the economist, Adam Smith, when entrepreneurs are unimpeded by legal or self-imposed moral constraint to protect the good of others, they are able to promote their own good and, as a result, provide the most efficient means of promoting the good of others (Baier, 1991, p. 201; see MacKinnon, p. 24). Such a view leads to the doctrine that, "if each pursues her own interest as she conceives of it, then the interest of everyone is promoted" (Baier, 1991, p. 200).
Objection: Apart from positing an "invisible hand" guiding the market processes, the common-good egoist makes the fallacy, ascribed to J.S. Mill, that if each person promotes her own interest, then everyone else’s interests are thereby promoted. "Clearly, this is a fallacy, for the interests of different individuals or classes may, and under certain conditions (of which the scarcity of necessities is the most obvious), do conflict. Then the interest of one is the detriment of the other" (Baier, 1991, p. 200).
Rational Egoism: Rational egoism is concerned with reasonable action.
Strong Rational Egoism: It is always rational to aim at one’s own greatest good, and never rational not to do so (Baier, 1991, p. 201).
Weak Rational Egoism: It is always rational to aim at one’s own greatest good, but not necessarily never rational not to do so (Baier, 1991, p. 201).
Argument For: When doing something does not prima facie appear to be in our interest, our doing said act requires that we justify our action by showing that it is in our interest, thereby justifying our action.
Objection: Such an approach to justifying actions in our own interest may be abused if we do not have criteria established to determine what the interests of agents amount to. If such criteria are established, such actions may be reasonable so long as they do not result in conflicts between agents. In such cases, creative middle ways are called for.
Ethical Egoism: Coupled with ethical rationalism—"the doctrine that if a moral requirement or recommendation is to be sound or acceptable, complying with it must be in accordance with reason"—rational egoism implies ethical egoism (Baier, 1991, p. 201).
Strong Ethical Egoism: It is always right to aim at one’s own greatest good, and never right not to do so (Baier, 1991, p. 201).
Weak Ethical Egoism: It is always right to aim at one’s own greatest good, but not necessarily never right not to do so (Baier, 1991, p. 201).
Argument For: If we accept rational egoism, and if we accept ethical rationalism, then we must accept ethical egoism. This is the case because if acting in one’s own self-interest is reasonable, then it is a moral requirement that one acts in one’s own self-interest.
Objection: Ethical egoism is incompatible with ethical conflict-regulation. Consider the following example from Kurt Baier, regarding the problem over whether it would be morally wrong for me to kill my grandfather so that he will be unable to change his will and disinherit me (1991, p. 202):
Assuming that my killing him will be in my best interest but detrimental to my grandfather, while refraining from killing him will be to my detriment but in my grandfather’s interest, then if ethical conflict-regulation is sound, there can be a sound moral guideline regulating this conflict (presumably by forbidding this killing). But then ethical egoism cannot be sound, for it precludes the interpersonally authoritative regulation of interpersonal conflicts of interest, since such a regulation implies that conduct contrary to one’s interest is sometimes morally required of one, and conduct in one’s best interest is sometimes morally forbidden to one. Thus, ethical egoism is incompatible with ethical conflict-regulation.
Conclusion: Rational egoism may have the fewest problems. The others flounder for the reasons mentioned. In fact, in light of the problems posed by ethical egoism for ethical conflict-regulation, the complaint raised by common-sense assessments seems warranted.
References:
Baier, Kurt. 1991. "Egoism" in A Companion to Ethics (ed. Singer). Oxford: Blackwell. 197-204
|
|
