About site: Philosophy/Philosophy of Science/Science, Technology and Society - Technological Determinism and Social Choice
Return to Society also Society
  About site: http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~kimble/teaching/cis/cis4.html

Title: Philosophy/Philosophy of Science/Science, Technology and Society - Technological Determinism and Social Choice The aim of this page is to explore in greater depth the controversy as to how far technology does, or does not, condition social change.
No_Place_Like_Homeland Proposes a Palestinian federation of three republics: Jewish, neutral and Arab, to enable both peoples to enjoy their right of return.

Institute_for_the_Study_of_Children,_Families_and_Communities Located at Eastern Michigan University, the Institute applies scholarly research and practical expertise to issues such as foster care and child welfare.

Trial_Ad_Notes News items and resources relating to trial advocacy, with a focus on Washington State by Mary Whisner, Bob Wayne.

After_Silence__Rape_and_My_Journey_Back Exploring attitudes toward rape and its survivors, and the process of recovery from trauma.

Catholic_Encyclopedia__Zosimus Biographical article providing an overview of Zosimus' contributions to Roman history.

Life\'s_Choices_-_A_Christian_Youth_Ministry,_Inc_ A non-denominational, residential program which provides safe shelter with comprehensive programming to at-risk, disadvantaged, pregnant and/or parenting teens, and their children, from Hampden County

  Alexa statistic for http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~kimble/teaching/cis/cis4.html





Get your Google PageRank






Please visit: http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~kimble/teaching/cis/cis4.html
  Related sites for http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~kimble/teaching/cis/cis4.html
    Vernon_L__Quinsey__True_Crime_Book_Reviews Professor of psychology at Queen's University lists true crime books he's read and gives his opinion about each.
    Vaccinations_-_HealthWorld_Online Information on the toxicity of vaccines, their adverse effects, long-term negative consequences, the new vaccines, and alternative vaccines.
    Charter_Schools_Development_Center_(CSDC) Provides technical assistance, training, and resources to charter school developers, operators, charter-granting agencies, and policy makers in California, nationally, and internationally.
    Thought_for_the_Day Thought for the Day from BBC Radio Leicester.
    Jesus_Metropolitan_Community_Church Indianapolis, Indiana. Worship times and location, contact information, FAQ, history, calendar.
    Deltgen Family history and photography compiled by Rob Deltgen, Luxemburg.
    Australian_Shipping Over 31,000 entries for Australian shipping arrivals and departures from 1788 to 1967. Selected passenger lists and diaries, crew lists, convict lists and information for other countries.
    Creative_Numerology Introductory information, report services and book extracts from Christine DeLorey.
    Nostradamus_World_War_III_2002 Explains Nostradamus' prophecies of a third world war that starts in 2002, with links to other sites and books about prophecies of WWIII.
    Free_West_Papua_Movement Organization trying to liberate West Papua (Irian Jaya) from Indonesia. Site includes writings of, and an interview with, its leader Moses Werror.
    Soulmate_Connections Spiritual consultant with twenty five years of experience offers tarot card and psychic readings by phone, email, or chat. Includes a profile, details of services provided, ordering instructions, FAQs
    Kiwanis_Club_of_Idar-Oberstein,_Germany Club meeting times, division and club leadership, membership and contact information
    Christian_Mission_Aid Non-denominational organization based in Michigan, provides assistance, training, and resources for relief and development projects in East African countries.
    Thoughts_Out_Of_Season E-text, Part One.
    Introduction_to_the_Frankfurt_School A concise look at the background and history of this group. Features a summary of each member's contribution to contemporary social thought.
    The_First_Church_of_Historical_Jesus Promotes belief in the example of Jesus without requiring belief in his divinity or even in God. Recommended reading, mailing list, merchandise, and links.
    The_Bald_Boy_Keloğlan_and_the_Most_Beautiful_Girl_in_the_World Exploration by H. Paksoy of Keloğlan, an archetype from Turkish folktales, illustrated with stories.
    Complex_Litigation_Integrators,_LLC New Jersey firm emphasizing data discovery and document management.
    Moshe_Strikes_The_Rock Discussion of the sins of Moses and Aaron from a Jewish perspective, including rabbinic commentary by Ibn Ezra and Rashi.
    Ven__Robert_Anderton English priest and friend of William Marsden. The two were shipwrecked, whereupon they were arrested for being priests coming into England from abroad, and tried on the "bloody question." They were ha
This is websites2007.org cache of m/ as retrieved on 2008.10.11 websites2007.org's cache is the snapshot that we took of the page as we crawled the web. The page may have changed since that time.
Technological Determinism and Social ChoiceYou are here: CIS HOME > TOPICS[Previous Topic] [Return to Overview] [Next Topic]

(4) Technological Determinism and Social Choice

Aims and objectives

The aim of this section of the course is to explore in greater depth the controversy as to how far technology does, or does not, condition social change. A useful starting point for these discussions would be:Engagement with media: Shaping and Being ShapedWhich outlines the various different views on exactly what constitutes technological determinism and argues that the media through which we view the world media give shape to our experience of it.Technological or Media DeterminismWhich develops the theme of the theme of the above paper in greater detail and provides a list of references and related reading as well as some web links.For a discussion of the way in which computer based technology 'impacts' on an organization, you might also like to look at the following papers:Computer Based Information Systems and Managers' WorkWhich provides some examples of how both technology and the decisions made by managers can be seen as shaping the way that computer based technology is used in an organization.The Concept of AppropriationWhich discusses the difference between French and British perspectives on the ways in which the relationship between technology, people and organizations is viewed in both countries.Finally, there are some web links below that you may find useful.

Overview/Summary

Early works assumed technology to be an objective, external force that had deterministic impacts on organizational properties such as structure. Later studies focused upon the human aspect of technology and focused on strategic choice models and social action. Despite years of investigative effort, definition and measurement, there is little or no compelling evidence for the role of technology in organizational affairs.Two dimensions of technology are discussed in this lecture: scope and role.Scope - What is defined as comprising of the technology?Role - How is the interaction between the technology and organization defined?ScopeThe lectures will discuss two views that reflect claims to generalisability.The first conceptualizes technology as hardware, i.e. the equipment, machines and instruments humans use in productive (either physical or informational) processes. These have lead to either context dependent definitions of the scope of technology, as the range of hardware across industries and organizations differ, or broad definitions that have little informational value.These problems lead some researchers to develop a second view of technology as "social technologies". Tasks, technique and knowledge are bound together in a single construct, e.g. "tecnik". This attempt to broaden the definition of technologies to include "social technologies" however has lead to boundary and measurement ambiguity. It also tends to ignore or undervalue the possibility of interaction between different elements and the effects of human mediation in the ways in which a technology can be used.RoleThe lectures will then discuss three theoretical frameworks that reflect philosophical viewpoints.The first (technological imperative model) views technology as an objective, external force that had deterministic impacts on organizational properties. The second (strategic choice model) focused on the human action aspect of technology and saw technology as a product of shared interpretations or interventions. The third (Technology as a trigger for structural change model) puts forward a soft deterministic viewpoint that argues that technology is a relatively objective, external force but that the impacts on organizational properties are moderated by human actions and the contingencies of organizational context.The technological imperative model. The technological imperative model examines the impact of a technology upon organizational dimensions such as structure, size, performance, degree of centralization as well as more individualistic dimensions such as job satisfaction, task complexity, skill levels, productivity, etc. It posits that technology exerts an independent, uni-directional and causal influence over humans and organizations similar in nature to the laws of physical sciences. A "softer" version of the technological determinist model allows for the influence of the technology to be mediated by contextual variables.The strategic choice model. The strategic choice model does not view technology as an external object but as an intentional product of human actions, design and appropriation. Three research foci are discernible.The Socio-Technical Perspective. Here the focus is on how the technology is physically constructed thorough the choices and decisions made by human actors. Technology is not immutable but is a dependent variable contingent on other forces in the organization, most notably powerful organizational actors. The Socio-Technical school argues that outcome such as job satisfaction or productivity can be manipulated by jointly optimizing the fit between social and technical factors. These analyses tend to assume that once a technology has been designed to optimize the socio-technical fit a "better" performance will inevitably result.The social Constructionist perspective. Here the focus is on how the shared interpretations of the meaning of a certain technology arise and affect the development of and interaction with that technology. While this perspective can be useful in examining how the meaning of a technology is created and sustained, it inevitably underplays the material and structural aspects of the technology.The Marxian Perspective. In this case the focus is on the manner in which a technology is deployed to further the political and economic interests of powerful groups of social actors. The concern is with the social construction of technology at the point of initiation rather than at the point of use. Managers and/or designers are portrayed as having the authority and ability to shape the technology whereas the users and workers are portrayed as being relatively powerless.Technology as a trigger for structural change. This perspective portrays technology as an intervention into the relationship between human agency and organizational structure. Technology can trigger a structural change by altering institutionalized roles and patterns of interaction. Technology does exert an influence on organizational structure but the precise outcome depends on the specific historical processes in which it is embedded. Thus technology is viewed as a social object whose meaning, defined by the context of its use, may change although its physical form remains fixed over time.Building on the material in previous topic the following areas will also be covered in the lectures:Models and frameworksTechnological determinist modelsFour Social Choice modelsWeb modelsStructuration TheoryUsing material from the lectures, your reading and the web sites your objectives should be to identify:The different classes of models and frameworks that might be used to describe/explain the "impact" of computer technology.How these models/frameworks might be applied in different circumstances.The changes in the nature of society related to the growth of IT.The effect that IT might have on society.The effect that society might have on the use of IT.You should attempt to develop an understanding of the differing perspectives covered in the lecture and your reading and how they might be applied.

Books

See any of the books from the books sectionorIT(1) - Information Technology: Social Issues - A Reader, Ed. Finnegan. R, Salaman. G and Thompson. K., The Open University/Hodder and Stoughton., 1994.Chap 1, The case for Technological Determinism, C. Freeman, pp 5- 18.Chap 4, Value conflicts and Social Choice in Electronic Payment Systems, R. Kling, pp 38 - 57.IT(2) - Information Technology and Society: A Reader, Ed Heap. N., Thomas. R., Einon. G. and MacKay. H., The Open University/Sage, 1994.Part 1 - Introduction, R. Thomas. pp 11 -14.The Social Shaping of Technology, D. Edge, pp. 14 - 33.Theorizing the IT/Society Relationship, H. MacKay, pp. 41 - 54A Gendered Socio-Technical Construction: The Smart House, Ann-Jorunn Berg, pp 74 - 90.SIT - Chaps 6 to 10 in Social Issues in Technology, Alcorn. P. Prentice Hall, 1997. pp 111 - 185.

Some Additional Reading (in library)

Bijker. N.E., Hughes. T.P. and Pinch. T.J. (Eds), The social construction of Technological Systems, MIT Press, 1987.Hirschheim. R. and Klein. H. Four paradigms of information system development, Communications of the ACM. Vol. 32, no 10 (1989) pp 1199 - 1216.Kling. R and Iacono. S., Computing as an Occasion for Social Control. Journal of Social Issues, 40, 3 (1984), pp 77-96.Buchanan D and Boddy D, "Organizations in the Computer Age: Technological Imperatives and Strategic Choice", 1983, Gower.Child, J. (1972), Organizational Structure, Environment and Performance: The Role of Strategic Choice, Sociology Vol 6, No 1, pp 1-22.De Greene KB, Long wave cycles of Sociotechnical change and innovation: A macropsychological perspective, Journal of Occupational Psychology, 1988, vol 61, pp. 7-23.Orlikowski. W.J, The Duality of Technology: rethinking the concept of technology in organizations. Organization Science. 3(3), 1992. pp. 398 - 427.Kling R. and Scacchi. W. The web of computing: Computer Technology as Social Organization. Advances in Computers, Vol 21, 1982. pp 2 - 89 .

Web Links

Brief definitions of technological and social determinismDeterminism (Wikipedia)Technological Determinism (Wikipedia)Social shaping of technology (Wikipedia)Social construction of technology (Wikipedia)Technological Determinism (Principia Cybernetica)Technological Questions and Issues (Trinity Church of England School)Social Aspects of Technology and Science (Records of course meetings at UC San Diago)Articles and papersWhat is the Social Shaping of Technology? -Robin Williams and David Edge review research that addresses 'the social shaping of technology'.The Mutual Shaping of Technology and Society in Videotex Newspapers: Beyond the Diffusion and Social Shaping Perspectives -An article by Pablo J. Boczkowski. (You will need an Athens password to access this article).Men's Work, Women's Work: TheSocial Shaping of Technology in Academic Libraries -Looks at the effects of technology on social relations and their dynamics in University librariesTechnological Determinism -Notes by Robert O. Keel, Department of Sociology, University of Missouri-St. LouisTechnological Determinism, Colonialism, and Postcolonialism -A brief bibliographic essay that attempts to tie these three ideas together.Technological Determinism of Marshall McLuhan -Slide show by Whittenburg/Shedletsky from University of Southern MaineMarshall McLuhan Meets William Gibson in "Cyberspace"' -By Michael E. Doherty in the Computer-Mediated Communication Magazine.[Previous Topic] [Return to Overview] [Next Topic]_uacct = "UA-2986312-1";urchinTracker();
 

The

aim

of

this

page

is

to

explore

in

greater

depth

the

controversy

as

to

how

far

technology

does,

or

does

not,

condition

social

change.

http://www-users.cs.york.ac.uk/~kimble/teaching/cis/cis4.html

Technological Determinism and Social Choice 2008 October

dvd rental

dvd


The aim of this page is to explore in greater depth the controversy as to how far technology does, or does not, condition social change.

Rules

© 2008 Internet Explorer 5+ or Netscape 6+
Recommended Sites: 1. Arts - Business - Computers - Games - Health - Home - Kids and Teens - News - Recreation - Reference - Regional - Science - Shopping - Society - Sports - World Miss Gallery - Top Anime Hentai - DVD rental by mail - Fast Loans - Mortgage - Credit Cards - Free Advertising - Computer Programming Tutorials
2008-10-11 14:24:23

Copyright 2005, 2006 by Webmaster
Websites is cool :) 11Hotel Brussels - Kalendarze Reklamowe - Online Bingo - Poker - Bingo