| Related sites for http://www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Anth/AnthTche.htm |
| Preutt_org Labor activist advocating reform in the United Association of Plumbers union exposes alleged mismanagement by union officials. | | Dr_Chettawut_Tulayaphanich Details of gender reassignment surgery services offered. Located in Bangkok, Thailand. | | Pau,_Timothy About Timothy, photos of him and his friends and a links page. | | Wold,_Jonathan Collection of digital artwork and writings. Includes personal photography, blog, poems, essays, and information about some of his past and future business ventures. | | Vanden_Berghe,_Chris Photographs of his family and friends during vacations to different countries, including the U.S., Switzerland, and Belgium, a brief biography, a curriculum vitae, and his friends' homepages. | | Vanovschi,_Vitalii A photo gallery and resume highlghtng his projects, awards won, and education. | | Tone_Family Uniting lineages worldwide. Includes historical information, publications and family list. | | Conflict_Zone_Logistics South African group supplying relief services to war zones and post-war areas. Resources for education, agriculture, sanitation, disarming land mines, and medical care. | | Moro_Islamic_Liberation_Front A profile of the Islamic separatist movement in the Philippines. | | The_Anti-Individualist_Philosophy_of_Emerson_and_Thoreau How Emerson and Thoreau failed to apply their non-conformist ideas consistently, making their philosophy of transcendentalism one of conformity rather than liberation. | | Sacred_Magick_Forums Premiere forums for all topics related to the Western Mystery traditions. | | Caveat_Suffragator Conservative commentary on Rhode Island and Ohio, the United States, and Canada. | | The_Algebra_of_Infinite_Justice Operation Enduring Freedom is ostensibly being fought to uphold the American Way of Life, but it'll probably end up undermining it completely, writes Arundhati Roy. (September 29, 2001) | | Kilo_3/5_Desert_Storm_Stories_Page The personal account and photographs from a US Marine infantryman. | | Classification_of_American_Wealth History and genealogy of the wealthy families of America, from colonial times until present. | | MAR_-_Bulgarian_Youth_Alliance_for_Development Organizes youth workcamps in Bulgaria with many volunteers from around the world, focusing on youth and democracy-building. | | Spirit_of_Hosea_Audio_Archive Sermons & Radio Broadcasts about marriage, divorce, remarriage and more. | | Key-Way-Tin_Bible_Institute An evangelical native discipleship school at Lac la Biche, AB Canada | | What_Strikes_My_Fancy A personal web log from a Scientologist covering a wide range of topics about church activities. | | Animal_Net News and information about animals in need. |
|
20th WCP: Philosophical-Anthropological Approach to Historic-Cultural Research
Philosophical Anthropology
Philosophical-Anthropological Approach to Historic-Cultural Research
Lioudmila Tchernaya, Institute for Cultural Research, Troitsk, Russia
ABSTRACT:
This approach holds that the problem of humanity determines the
history of culture. On the basis of theory developed by Max Scheler, I
try to work out the main characteristics of cultural process, the
typology of culture, and the periodization of culture. The humanities in
Russia are in the midst of a methodological crisis now, and I hope that
this approach will help us obtain a fuller understanding of
culture.
There's not a secret that
Russian Humanities are in a methodological crisis now. Our scientists look
for new Methods and Approaches using the Conceptions of Western Science.
Among them American Anthropology is the most popular in the last years
throughout the World. Philosophers are interested in "Ecological
Anthropology" which learns the adaptation of people to environment
especially (see: Sahlin M. Evolution: specific and general// Theory in
Anthropology. Manners R., Paplan D. (eds). Chicago.1968; Hatch E. The
growth of economics, subsistence and ecological studies in American
Anthropology// Journal of Anthropological Reseach. Vol.29.1973). Many
American scientists prefer the neoevolution Method with the analyses of
Race, Nation and others ethnic or social groups (see, for example: Lazlo
E. Evolution: The Grans Syntethesis. Boston.1987). Among new approaches we
can see some connected with Psychology. (See: Bock Ph.K. Rethinking
Psychological Anthropology. N.Y. 1988; Berry J., Poortinga Y., Legall M.,
Dasen P. Cross-Cultural Psychology: Research and Applications. Cambridge,
1992; Cole M. Cultural Psychology. Cambridge, 1996; Coult A.D. Psychodelic
Anthropology. Philadelphia, 1997 and others). The authors write about
identification of Person, "socialization" and "culturalization" of
children, about "ethological" method, which helps us to understand the
interaction between Person and Society. Psychological Anthropology takes
the first place in working out the theme "Culture and Personality" now,
but it resolves this theme in the direction of Man adaptation to the
modern Society.
There is, however, the Conception, in which the development of Culture
seems to be depended on the solution of the Problem of Person-"new
Philosophical Anthropology". My special interest is connected, first of
all, with this Conception as a Theory of Culture. New Philosophic
Anthropology is well developed in Western Science, but practically unknown
in Russia. Our philosophers only begin to study the Conception of it's
founder-Max Scheler (see: Max Scheler. Izbranniye proizvedeniya. M.,
1994;). Max Scheler created the global Theory of the historical Process as
a penetration of Man into his own substance, as a permanent search for
"selfness", "independent being into itself". Philosophic Anthropology puts
forward the Hipothesis that Man tells from animals not by intellect and
ability of choice but some "Spirit" which is in opposition to Life
("Vitalism") as a whole. The centre of this Spirit is Person, Man only,
but people had been looking for it in Mythology, Religion, etc. The forms
of the "Absolute Centre" of Man may be different: Cosmos, God and others.
Giving the definition of Man as a "creature surpassing himself and the
World", Max Scheler affirms that "the conduction opened to the World" and
"never stopped passion for penetration into the open World's
space-Cosmos-had obliged Man for looking for how to implant his Absolute
Centre outside of the World". The development of History goes as a
difficult complicated Process of comprehending by Humanity the Relation to
Man's Absolute Centre. This is the most fundamental Idea of Philosophical
Anthropology.
The followers of Max Scheler selected different sides of the Haritage
of famous philosopher and now work them out. H.Plesner suggested three
fundamental laws of Philosophical Anthropology (Plesner H. Gesammelte
Schriften. Bd.1.F./M.1980), M.Landmann put the development of World's
Culture in the connection with this
Conception (Landmann M. Fundamental Anthropologie. Bonn. 1979).
A.Deeken and others sociologists develop Scheler's Moral Philosophy.
Deeken wrote, that the word "genius" would seem to be the most appropriate
term to characterize Max Scheler. His philosophical insights have deeply
influenced a great number of contemporary minds...
Amoung the men who came under Scheler's influence are Nicolai Hartmann,
Ortega-y-Gasset, Merleau Dempf, Karl Mannheim, Jacques Maritain, Dietrich
von Hildebrand, Martin Heidegger, Gabriel Marcel and others" (see: Deeken
A.S.J. Process and permanence in ethics. Max Scheler's Moral Philosophy.
N.Y. 1974. P.1). Many interesting works have been dedicated to Scheler's
system of Value-Person-Types, his theory of "Kairos" as a Memand of the
Present Hour, the Hierarchy of values and others. But my special interest
is connected with the Research of Philosophical Anthropology as a
Methodology of Culture.
The ideas of Max Scheler, H.Plesner, M.Landmann and other philosophers
put the foundation-stone of my own Typology of Culture. New Philosophical
Anthropology may be named "the Theory of relativity" in the Culturology of
the XX-th Century: it postulates the Relation between Man and his Absolute
Centre as a essence of World Historic- Cultural Process. On these grounds
I went to philosophical-anthropological characteristics of Cultural
Process:
(1) The principle of "relativity" and that one of "absolutness". As to
his "Absolute Centre" Man can be either in the state of his essence or in
the state of stability when the Problem of Man is considered to be solved
and this solution is adopted as a final.
(2) "Anthropocentrism" and "Theocentrism". When the Society is looking
for new Idea of Man, this one becomes the Centre of all connections. In
other case Man seems to be so named "empty vessel", receiving traditional
models of the behaviour.
(3) The principle of the "novelty" and that one of the "antiquity".
Under the aegis of "novelty" is proceding the new system of values in
Culture; when the self-consciousness of Culture acknowledges the existing
Idea of Man as a final and an absolute "truth", the whole mechanism of
cultural connections will be directed to the preservation of
"antiquity".
(4) The "dynamism"and the "statism" of cultural Process. The cultural
system acts either dynamically or statically, what depends on the state of
the concrete Society in the concrete historical Period: if the Problem of
Man seems to be solved, the Culture is in the phase of static, if, on the
contrary, the intensive search for a new solution of this Problem is going
on, the Culture enters in the phase of dynamics.
(5) "Open" Society and Man or "closed" Society and Man. I use this term
-"open"-in specific meaning, connected with the solution of the Problem of
Man: when the old System of values is broken and Man has lost the support
in it, he becomes "defenceless", "open" to the different influences over
him both positive and negative. In this time we can see the results of
this phenomenon in increasing of the discoveries in all spheres of Life,
the different contacts with the forces belonging to the other world; in
creation of the new genres in Art, Literature, ect. It's to be noted, that
"open" Man has high creative potential. At a time when the Problem of Man
seems largely solved, people receive the formed System of Values and feel
themselves defended.
(6) The development of the traditions or the dogmatisation of them: the
"traditional culture" differs from the "tradition in the Culture", because
in the first case the culture lives within the limits of the tradition as
in it's own present norms, in the second case the culture comprehends the
traditions as it's own Past, into which it's incorporated.
(7) The Historism and Dogmatism as all anterior characteristics aren't
absolute, they are relative. But in the Period of search for Absolute
Centre the sense of Historism begins to play the essential role in the
Society's consciousness. Looking for new foundations of Man's Life the
Society is obliged to revalue it's History and find there new points of
stabilization. On the contrary when the Idea of Man culminates it would be
turned in a Dogma inevitably.
(8) As I noted before the system of genres depends from the situation
of "open" or "closed" Culture and Man. At the same time all others
positions influence on it, especially the principle of "novelty". The last
makes the process of creation of new genres in the Literature, Art, Music,
etc. very intensive. Some of new genres after the Transition Period
disappear forever, others begin to develope successfully. The conservation
of old system of genres in Literature, Art, Music, etc. is the effect of
the historical-cultural situation as a whole.
(9) Well-developed self-consciousness or undeveloped self-consciousness
are connected first of all with the Author's self-consciousness. The epoch
of "relativity", anthropocentrism", "dynamism", etc. makes the "Roal Road"
to the "New Man" with well-developed consciousness of his value as a
Person. His efforts for creation another Conception of Man incarnate in
himself and in the Culture as a whole. The Type of Person is a historical
definition, which Max Scheler and other philosophers considered the most
important result of the Cultural Development.
(10) The characteristics suggested by Oswald Spengler-the principles of
inequality and equality; quality and quantity-finish our List of
characteristics, but they have a great significance. I have in mind that
in the phase of arrest of development of the new Idea of Man, the indices
of equality and quantity predominate in the Culture. I have named the main
principle positions only. Starting from them we must regard the problem of
cultural Typology. I can suggest the Typology of Culture on the ground of
"Personal" or "Non-personal" types.
"Personal" type
"Non-personal" type
The principle of relativity
The principle of absoluteness
Anthropocentrism
Theocentrism
The principle of "novelty"
The principle of "antiquity"
Dynamism
Statism
"Open" Society and Man
"Closed" Society and Man
Historism
Dogmatism
The development of Traditions
Formalisation of Traditions
The creation of new genres in Literature, Art, etc.
The conservation of old genresin Literature, Art, etc.
Well-developed self-consciousness
Undeveloped self-consciousness
The principle of inequality
The principle of equality
The principle of quality
The principle of quantity
The proposed Typology may be included in the group of historical
approaches to Culture. The World's Cultural Process looks as a periodical
change of "personal" and "non-personal" types: every new Period begins
with "personal" phase and ends with "non-personal". The most interesting
epochs are the Transition periods in which the old and new Concepts of Man
unite in a whole. There is a further point to be made there that the
historical data of the Transition Period of Russian Culture from the
Middle Ages to the New Time have confirmed our hypothesis, the theory of
cultural tipes was fully established in it. These data were published in
my book "The Transition Period of the Russian Culture from the Middle Ages
to the New Time: philosophical-anhtropological approach" M.: "Yziki
russkoi kulturi",1999. Few words concerning the
Philosophical-Anthropological Periodization of the History of Culture.
Certainly, it is connected with new solution of the Problem of Man: the
Period of "Body", which corresponds to the Heathen period, when Man was
estimated as a part of Common Cosmic "Body"; the Period of "Soul"
(Medieval period, when the Soul was the dominant of the decision of the
Problem of Man); the Period of "Mind" (New Time's Culture); the Period of
"Existence" (the Culture of the XX-th Century). As it's clear, this
Periodization is in the accordance with common historical Periodization,
accepted in Modern World's Science, but, of cause, our Periodization will
make alterations in it.
My research is in a state of active development now (See: Tchernaya L.
The "New Philosophical Anthropology" by Max Scheler and the History of
Culture// The Problems of Philosophy. M., 1999. 17). I am sure it is
worth further investigation and hope my work in this sphere will help us
to obtain a fuller understanding of the Phenomenon of Personality, on the
one hand, and the development of Culture, on the other hand. Philosophical
Anthropology gives us the unique chance to create the model of unified
World Culture development instead of the many local Cultures (or
Civilizations) Paradigma. I am afraid only (after N. A. Berdiaev) of
simplification of such a Phenomenon as a Man.
Paideia logo design by Janet L. Olson. All Rights Reserved
|
|
