| Related sites for http://www.counterpunch.org/snell1.html |
| Impact__Issue_on_Violence_Against_Women_with_Developmental_or_Other_Disabilities Examines violence as it impacts women with developmental and other disabilities - what we know, what we don't know, and what needs to be done to prevent it and to help women recover from it. | | The_History_of_Belarussian_Jewry Alex Friedman's research on Belarussian Jewry. Statistical data, articles, personal researches. English, Russian and Belarussian versions. | | Wikipedia__Rapture History and summary of various viewpoints. | | Some_Paradoxes The following paradoxes are described: liar paradox, Zeno paradox, Petersburg paradox and Simpson paradox. With some practical concequences. | | New_Age_Today Features a site each day that promotes universal understanding, and provides tools, gifts, products and services for positive growth. | | Steuben_Day_Observance_Association_of_Philadelphia_and_Vicinity Information reagrding the Annual German - American Steuben Parade of Philadelphia and other events in the Delaware Valley. | | Yamamoto,_Robert Robert Yamamoto and family from Arizona including Briana, Sonia, Alex, and Zuki. | | Yi_Jing_Algebra A contemporary, logical and structural perspective on the ancient Chinese classic of wisdom and divination (Yi Jing) from Andreas Schöter. Sitemap, consultation page, workshop information, PDFs and w | | Anti-Racism_Information_Service_(ARIS) Information on ARIS's activities in support at the UN's Committee for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), and documentation about racial discrimination and related topics. | | Chancellor_of_Germany_-_Wikipedia Article on German heads of government, includes a comprehensive historical list. | | Raw-Food_Cuisine Offers classes and personalized instruction in vegetarian cooking and raw food cuisine. Private chef services are also available. Located in Chicago, Illinois, USA. | | Articles_by_Larry_Phillips Various articles on education and education reform, including the standards movement, school based management, and school councils. | | Guardian_Unlimited_Special_Report__North_and_South_Korea Ongoing news, analysis, and commentary includes timeline, interactives, weblog, audio and video. Extensive links. | | Circle_Angkur_-_San_Diego Based in San Diego, California (USA) members of the CoG; dedicated to extensive energy work for increased self-knowledge and mastery in service to the Divine; to teaching and worship of the Divine in | | History_House__Put_it_on_George\'s_Tab A brief look at Washington's extravagant expense account while General of the Continental Army. | | IgniteYourFaith_com Dating advice, quizzes, humor, personal stories, and articles about music and faith for Christian Teens teens. From Christianity Today. [RSS] | | Philosophy_and_Food A short introduction to the topic by Jeremy Iggers. Published in 2001 in Philosophy Now. | | Four_Directions_Institute__Tlingit Tribal profile, timeline, and links. | | ThreeScoops_Online An online publication for young African American women | | Alpha_Phi_Omega_-_Eastern_Rizal_Alumni_Association An alumni chapter representing the towns of Binangonan, Cardona, Morong, Teresa, Baras, Tanay, Pililla and Jalajala. |
|
Karen Snell: Torture By Proxyhome/ subscribe/ about us/ books /archives/ search/ links /feedbackRead Cockburn and St.Clair's Whiteout:the CIA, Drugs and the Press and discover how the CIA gavea helping hand to the opium lords who took over Afghanistan, thusushering the Taliban into power. CounterPunch: Complete Coverageof 9/11 and the War on AfghanistanNew Print Edition ofCounterPunch Published October 31:Another special 8-page edition with stories on: How Monica LewinskySaved the Social Security System; CNN debates the pros and consof torture; a history of the Palmer Raids; Smearing Rep. CynthiaMcKinney; David Lloyd and Rick Berg profile Zalmay Khalilzad,Bush's Afghan playmaker; Blind Predator dupes the New Yorker'sSeymour Hersh; Kipling's Jezail guns. Available exclusively tosubscribers. SubscribeNow! A Seven Part Special Report by Douglas Valentine, Author of The Phoenix Program Homeland Insecurity: The Politics of Terror in America by Douglas Valentine November 9, 2001 Karen Snell Torture By Proxy John Troyer A New Kind of Activism Tariq Ali Q & A About the War Michael Colby Schoolgirl Gets Booted for Anti-war Views November 8, 2001 Mokhiber/Weissman The Cipro Rip-Off Mitchel Cohen The Smear Campaign Against Nancy Oden Steve Perry American Roulette  A Photographic Journal of Life in an Afghan Refugee Camp By Judith Mann November 7, 2001 Bahour/Dahan Placebo Peace Plan Tom Turnipseed Bush Gives Billions to His Oil Buddies Cockburn/St. Clair Greens, Airports and National ID Cards Dr. Susan Block Ayatollah Asscroft Brian J. Foley Bombing Campaign Not "Self-Defense" Under International Law November 6, 2001 Mark Scaramella Where's That Red Cross Money Going C.G. Estabrook Our Torturers Sheperd Bliss Scott Nearing on War Rep. Ron Paul Underwriting the Taliban Tariq Ali The General Who Came to Dinner Evan Ravitz Stop the War Through Direct Democracy Steve Perry Hunger in Afghanistan November 5, 2001 Patrick Cockburn Living in the Minefields David Price Terror and Indigenous People November 3, 2001 Declan McCullagh Nancy Oden Interview Daniel Wolff The Memphis Blues Again Mark Weisbrot War on Civilians Dave Marsh How the RIAA (and the FBI) Cheat Musicians Robert Jensen Speaking Out Against War on Campus November 2, 2001 CounterPunch Wire Green Party Leader Detained at Maine Airport; Prevented from Boarding Any Plane Alexander Cockburn FBI Eyes Torture November 1, 2001 Dean Baker Dying for Patents Sami Amarah US Attempts to Recruit Russian Vets of Afghan War Molly Secours Where Are the Voices of Reason? Let the Women Be Heard William Blum Unleashing the CIA October 31, 2001 Tom Turnipseed Terrorize the Poor, Subsidize the Rich Chris Clarke Thank God for Berkeley Steve Perry The Silent Genocide Resources: 100s of Links About 9/11 CounterPunch: Complete Coverage of 9/11 and Its Aftermath Five Days That Shook The World: Seattle and Beyond  By Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St. Clair Photos by Allan Sekula (Click Here to Order from CounterPunch Online at 20% Off Amazon.com's price!) INSIDE Subscribe Online! EXCLUSIVE TO COUNTERPUNCH SUBSCRIBERS Published Oct. 15, 2001 8-Page Special Issue War Diary CIA's Assassination Plan a History of Torture in US Prisons bin Laden and Bush Business Connections Aisha Ikramuddin on the Hidden Hype of US Food Bombs Peter Linebaugh on Pakistan Christopher Hitchens' Love for Mrs. Thatcher Jiang Zemin Tells Bush: Nuke 'Em Search CounterPunch Read Whiteout and Find Out How the CIA's Backing of the Mujahideen Created the World's Most Robust Heroin Market and Helped to Finance the Rise of the Taliban and Osama bin Laden Whiteout: CIA, Drugs & the Press by Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St. Clair  The Memphis Blues Again: Six Decades of Memphis Music Photographs Photos by Ernest Withers Text by Daniel Wolff  The New Intifada: Resisting Israel's Apartheid Edited by Roane Carey  A Pocket Guide to Environmental Bad Guys by James Ridgeway and Jeffrey St. Clair  The Phoenix Program by Douglas Valentine  Al Gore: A User's Manual by Cockburn and St. Clair  Buy This Explosive New Book at an Amazing Discount! Reviews of Gore: a User's Manual Private Warriors by Ken Silverstein  CounterPunch's Booktalk November 9, 2001 Torture by Proxy By Karen L. Snell The Recorder To the French, Kenneth Starr is known as the "Ayatollah sexuelle," but after his recent comments in The Washington Post suggesting that we should cast aside traditional civil liberties in the fight against terrorism, just plain "Ayatollah" seems more fitting. According to Starr, five justices of the U.S. Supreme Court have signaled that they would give "heightened deference to the judgments of the political branches with respect to matters of national security," and thus, would be willing to bend the constitutional rules in a case involving terrorism. Starr's comments provide encouragement to the Department of Justice, which, according to the Post, is reportedly contemplating the use of "drugs or pressure tactics" when terrorism suspects refuse to speak, or "extraditing the suspects to allied countries where security services sometimes employ threats to family members or resort to torture." An FBI official quoted in the Post recognizes that such evidence would be inadmissible, but says that "legally admissible evidence in court may not be the be-all and end-all." Attorney General John Ashcroft echoed this sentiment during a recent appearance on ABC's "Nightline." Starr's attempt to justify the unthinkable is worthy of Osama bin Laden himself. According to a handbook that American prosecutors have suggested was used by Al Queda to train members of the network, "religious scholars have permitted beating ... . It is permitted to strike the nonbeliever who has no covenant until he reveals the news, information, and secrets of his people." Starr and Ashcroft appear to have forgotten that the reason evidence obtained by physical and mental pressure tactics is inadmissible in U.S. courts is because such tactics are unconstitutional. They violate the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, which the Supreme Court has aptly described as the "hallmark of our democracy," the "essential mainstay of our adversary system," which recognizes "the inviolability of the human personality." In our country we believe that when the government seeks to punish an individual, it must "produce the evidence against him by its own independent labors, rather than the cruel, simple expedient of compelling it from his own mouth." Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966). Certain interrogation techniques, including beatings and other forms of physical and psychological torture, have been declared so offensive to a civilized system that they must be condemned under the Due Process Clause of the Fifth and 14th Amendments. Brown v. Mississippi, 297 U.S. 278 (1936). Are these values so fragile that it takes one attack to throw them out the window? The use of pressure tactics, including torture by proxy, not only renders evidence obtained inadmissible in court. It's also a crime. And it is not just the person who physically or mentally assaults a suspect who is guilty. Any person who aids, abets, counsels or conspires to commit such acts is a criminal. Title 18, United States Code, Section 242, "Deprivation of rights under color of law," provides that officials who willfully subject any person to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured or protected by the Constitution or laws of the United States shall be imprisoned up to 10 years if bodily injury results. If the individual dies, the perpetrators are subject to the death penalty. Section 241 outlaws conspiracies against rights like those suggested by the government officials quoted in The Washington Post. And Section 2340A specifically extends the law against torture to nationals of the United States who commit or attempt to commit the crime abroad. Prosecutions can be brought under state laws as well, such as those pertaining to aggravated assault. To the extent that the government believes it can evade the criminal law by extraditing suspects to places where they are likely to be tortured, they are dead wrong. Not only would the conspiracy statute cover such conduct, it is forbidden by the Convention Against Torture, which the United States ratified in 1994. This treaty might serve as remedial reading for Starr and Ashcroft. It provides: The State parties to this Convention, Considering that, in accordance with the principles proclaimed in the Charter of the United Nations, recognition of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world, Recognizing that those rights derive from the inherent dignity of the human person, Considering the obligation of States under the Charter, ... to promote universal respect for, and observance of, human rights and fundamental freedoms, Having regard to article 5 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and article 7 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, both of which provide that no one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, ... Desiring to make more effective the struggle against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment throughout the world, Have agreed as follows: No State Party shall expel, return ("refouler") or extradite a person to another State where there are substantial grounds for believing that he would be in danger of being subjected to torture. This treaty is not just "international law," for which the U.S. has little respect. It has been codified as part of our law. It is the law of the land. Not surprisingly, however, the State Department has taken the position that when it comes to applying the treaty in the extradition context, its decisions are not subject to judicial review. In a case still pending, U. S. v. Cornejo-Barreto, 218 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2000), the 9th Circuit begged to differ. We can only hope that the court's approach withstands further appeal, in light of the Justice Department's position that extraditions for the very purpose of subjecting individuals to torture is permissible. It is a historical fact that in wartime America some civil liberties have been temporarily suspended. If the present government wishes to suspend civil liberties and violate both the law and fundamental human decency, let them come out and say so, and then try to explain to the American people exactly what it is we stand for and why we fight. It is more likely that the American people would have to explain it all to them. Because Americans know that even in the most extreme conception of a suspension of liberties, to subject any human being to torture, no matter how virulent an enemy he may be, is going far too far. And if there is one thing Kenneth Starr is an expert in, it's in going too far. Karen L. Snell, a partner at San Francisco's Clarence & Snell, specializes in constitutional litigation and international extradition. Related Stories: Alexander Cockburn, Wide World of Torture Alexander Cockburn, FBI Eyes Torture Douglas Valentine, Homeland Insecurity |
|
