|
|
| About site: Issues/Gun Control/Pro-Gun Rights - Guns in the Medical Literature -- Seattle |
Return to Society also Society |
| About site: http://teapot.usask.ca/cdn-firearms/Suter/med-lit/seattle.html |
Title: Issues/Gun Control/Pro-Gun Rights - Guns in the Medical Literature -- Seattle Refutation of study attempting to show Canada's gun laws resulted in lower rates of violence than in the U.S. |
| Alexa statistic for http://teapot.usask.ca/cdn-firearms/Suter/med-lit/seattle.html |
Please visit: http://teapot.usask.ca/cdn-firearms/Suter/med-lit/seattle.html
|
| Related sites for http://teapot.usask.ca/cdn-firearms/Suter/med-lit/seattle.html |
| Frolikov,_Alex Pages on his interests and photos. Tips and links about Java and HTML. | | Welsh,_Michael Contains personal information, music, and interests. | | New_School_University Department of Philosophy - New York, New York - MA, PhD | | Center_on_Budget_and_Policy_Priorities The Center is a research institute that conducts analyses on government policies and programs. | | New_Moon\'s_Book_of_Shadows Includes spells and rituals, correspondences, herbal information, chants and blessings. | | Urantia_Readers-International Worldwide organization who share in living and maintaining the revelation and mandates of the Urantia Book. Dedicated to dissemintating these teachings throughout the world. | | United_National_Indian_Tribal_Youth National network promoting personal development, citizenship and leadership; headquartered in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, USA. Program and event information, staff roster, links. | | American_Muslims_and_the_Global_Interfaith_Movement Encouraging the Islamic virtues of tolerance, kindness, respect, and cooperation towards people of other faiths as practiced by the Prophet of Islam. | | SI_Iceland Includes information about Icelandic Soroptimists and Icelandic Soroptimist Week. | | Phelan_Psychic_and_Witch_Practitioner Spell kits, psychic readings, aura cleansings and general items for sale. | | Reformation_Ink Primary sources and some later references from Luther, plus Calvin, Beza, and other Reformed theologians, and links to other writings and later responses to the 16th-century reforms. | | Stories_from_the_Thousand_and_One_Nights As translated by Edward William Lane (1909-14) and revised by Stanley Lane-Poole; e-text at Bartleby. | | On_Universal_Reconciliation Analytical articles [onsite and offsite] based upon New Testament Principles. | | The_Court Discussing the work of the Supreme Court of Canada. | | The_Elohim_Centre Fee based consultations, programs, and courses from beings from the star systems of Arcturus, Pleiades, and Sirius. | | Buddhism_in_Brazil Academic references on the expansion of Buddhism in Brazil. Also a web directory of Brazilian Buddhist centers, temples, monasteries, and Buddhist texts translated to Portuguese. | | Smart_Growth_Vermont Addresses the issue of sprawl and its effect on rural life. | | Dean_Hawk_Ministries Dedicated to spreading the creative power of God to youth pastors and leaders. Features an itinerary, conference information and a sample sermon audio file. | | Classic_Articles_of_Reformed_Theology Links to the writings of over 40 authors (from Alexander to Witsius) of essays in the historic Christian faith from a classic Reformed perspective. | | Legal_Information_Institute__Law_About_Bankruptcy An overview of bankruptcy law with links to key primary and secondary sources. |
|
This is websites2007.org cache of m/ as retrieved on 2008.11.18 websites2007.org's cache is the snapshot that we took of the page as we crawled the web. The page may have changed since that time.
|
Guns in the Medical Literature -- Seattle Previous Section -- Lawful Self-Defense, Next Section -- Foretelling the future, ContentsWhy are the Black and Hispanic homicide rates so high in Seattle?Sloan JH, Kellermann AL, Reay DT, et al. "Handgun Regulations, Crime, Assaults, and Homicide: A Tale of Two Cities." N Engl J Med 1988; 319: 1256-62.methodological and conceptual errors:attempted a simplistic single-cause interpretation of differences observed in demographically dissimilar cities and culturespurported to evaluate the efficacy of Canadian gun control without evaluating the situation before the lawthe Vancouver homicide rate increased 25% after the institution of the 1977 Canadian lawfailed to acknowledge that, except for Blacks and Hispanics, homicide rates were lower in the US than in CanadaSloan, Kellermann, and their co-authors attempted to prove that Canada's gun laws caused low rates of violence.[42]In their study of Vancouver, the authors failed to compare homicide rates before and after the law. As Blackman noted,[43]they had ignored or overlooked that Vancouver had 26% more homicides after the Canadian gun ban, an observation that should warrant scientific exploration and generate a healthy skepticism of the authors' foregone conclusions. Blackman's critique and analogy were so "on target" as to be amusing:"... The Vancouver-Seattle 'study' is the equivalent of testing an experimental drug to control hypertension by finding two ordinary-looking, middle class white men, one 25 years old and the other 40, and without first taking their vital signs, administering the experimental drug to the 25-year-old while giving the 40-year-old a placebo, then taking their blood pressure and, on finding the younger man to have a lower blood pressure, announcing in a 'special article' a new medical breakthrough. It would be nice to think that such a study would neither be funded by the taxpayers nor published in the [New England Journal of Medicine]."[43]Since its publication this article on gun control is among those most frequently cited, though this small scale (two cities) study has been thoroughly debunked by three large scale (national and multi-national) studies.[44][45][46]Kellermann and Sloan's biased interpretation of their data, asserting that guns are to blame for crime, assaults, and homicide, is even refuted by their own statistics.Kellermann and Sloan glossed over the disparate ethnic compositions of Seattle (12.1% Black and Hispanic; 7.4% Asian) and Vancouver (0.8% Black and Hispanic; 22.1% Asian). The importance? Despite typically higher prevalence of legal gun ownership amongst non-Hispanic-Caucasians in the US,[10]the homicide rate was lower for non-Hispanic-Caucasian Seattle residents (6.2 per 100,000) than for those in adjacent Vancouver, Canada (6.4). Only because the Seattle Black (36.6) and Hispanic (26.9) homicide rates were astronomic could the authors make their claim. [See Graph 14: "Ethnic and Racial Groups -- Seattle and Vancouver" & Graph 15: "Homicide Rates by Ethnic and Racial Group -- Seattle and Vancouver"]Could guns have some special evil influence over Blacks and Hispanics, but not others? Hardly! The authors failed to identify the inescapable truth. The roots of inner-city violence lie in the disruption of the family, the breakdown of society, desperate and demoralized poverty, promotion of violence by the media,[47][48]the profit of the drug trade, the pathology of substance abuse, child abuse, disrespect for authority, and racism -- not in gun ownership.For an even-handed and scholarly cross-cultural comparison of guns, violence, and gun control, the reader is referred to Kopel's compendium.[11]If one reviews homicide and suicide data, despite high levels of gun ownership and high levels of gun control, the US fares well in comparison with many countries, even those supposedly "non-violent" nations whose gun controls the US is invited to emulate, such as Japan. How do US homicide, suicide, and intentional fatality (combined homicide and suicide) rates compare with other nations? [See Graph 10: "International Suicide Rates Comparisons";Graph 16: "International Homicide Rates Comparisons"; and Graph 17: "International Intentional Fatality (Homicide+Suicide) Rates Comparisons"]Certainly the determinants of the levels of violence in a society are many and complex. Previous Section -- Lawful Self-Defense, Next Section -- Foretelling the future, Contents |
|
| |
Refutation | of | study | attempting | to | show | Canada's | gun | laws | resulted | in | lower | rates | of | violence | than | in | the | U.S. |
|
http://teapot.usask.ca/cdn-firearms/Suter/med-lit/seattle.html
Guns in the Medical Literature -- Seattle 2008 November
dvd rental
dvd
Refutation of study attempting to show Canada's gun laws resulted in lower rates of violence than in the U.S.
Rules
|
© 2008 Internet Explorer 5+ or Netscape 6+
|
|
Recommended Sites: 1.
Arts -
Business -
Computers -
Games -
Health -
Home -
Kids and Teens -
News -
Recreation -
Reference -
Regional -
Science -
Shopping -
Society -
Sports -
World
Miss Gallery
- Top Anime Hentai
- DVD rental by mail
- Debt Management - Credit - Internet Advertising - Credit Cards - Remortgaging
|